What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser and fridge? Here's why his belongings were sold (2024)

30 September 2022, 12:38

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser and fridge? Here's why his belongings were sold (1)

Evan Peters opens up about playing Jeffrey Dahmer

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser and fridge? Here's why his belongings were sold (2)

By Katie Louise Smith

Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser, fridge and the rest of the contents of his apartment were stopped from going to auction by Joseph Zilber, out of respect for the victims and their families. [CW // Extreme violence]

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

CONTENT WARNING: This article contains details of extreme violence that some readers may find triggering and disturbing.

The final episode of Netflix's DAHMER - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story series ends with Jeffrey Dahmer's death in prison, a court case involving his mother and father who are debating what to do with his brain (which was removed in the post mortem examination), and a determined final note from Glenda Cleveland (Niecy Nash) who wants to make sure Dahmer's victims are honoured and remembered.

Eager to find out what happened to the victim's families and Dahmer's apartment in the wake of his death, viewers are now wondering what actually became of all of Dahmer's belongings.

READ MORE: Does Jeffrey Dahmer's apartment still exist? What does it look like now?

The series tells viewers that Dahmer's apartment building was demolished, and it also briefly reveals what happened to the things in his apartment.

In reality, the true story behind what was originally meant to happen to things like Dahmer's dresser (where the gruesome polaroids were found), his fridge (where he had stored various human body parts) and the rest of his stuff, is pretty morbid. Thankfully, the plans were nixed and the victim's families were somewhat compensated.

What happened to Dahmer's belongings?

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser and fridge? Here's why his belongings were sold (5)

What happened to Dahmer's dresser and fridge?

In the first episode of the Netflix series, we see what the police discovered when they finally investigated Dahmer's apartment following Tracy Edward's escape.

In real life, the police found countless polaroid photos of the victims stashed away in his dresser. Elsewhere, they found body parts, vital organs and a human head in Dahmer's fridge, and more human remains scattered around his kitchen and in his freezer. An acid drum with three decomposing torsos was found in his bedroom, alongside severed body parts and skeletons hidden in wardrobes and dressers.

Dahmer was arrested and the evidence was removed from his apartment. Once his guilty verdict was announced, reports that his belongings were planning on being sold quickly made the rounds.

Initially, according to a 1996 report from The Washington Post, a court ruled that Dahmer's belongings – including the fridge, the dressers, the knives, and the rest of his furniture – would be auctioned off to raise money for the families.

However, due to fears that they would be sold off to serial killer fanatics and "murder-abilia hunters", who would in turn likely make even more money off them, a Milwaukee civic group began to raise enough money to buy them outright, with the intent on completely destroying everything out of respect for the victims.

READ MORE: Is Lionel Dahmer still alive? Here's why Jeffrey Dahmer's dad thinks he became a killer

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser and fridge? Here's why his belongings were sold (6)

How much money did Dahmer's victims get?

Joseph Zilber, head of the civic group, pledged $407,225 to buy Dahmer's fridge, the dressers, the knives, and everything else that was up for sale. (The items also included the acid drum, clothing, bedsheets, saw blades, sledgehammers and things like records, tapes, bicycles and figurines.)

An earlier offer was rejected by lawyer Thomas Jacobson, who represented 8 of the families of Dahmer's victims, because he thought an auction would raise at least $1 million.

Eventually, the Milwaukee civil group worked closely with the families, who accepted the offer "in a very close vote," allowing them to be incinerated rather than auctioned off. As a result, the Washington Post reports that, after lawyer fees, $32,000 was to be given to each of the 11 families who were involved in the decision.

A further report from AP News confirmed that all of Dahmer's furniture and belongings were destroyed in June 1996. In the series, we see various items from Dahmer's apartment being destroyed on a landfill site.

READ MORE: Jeffrey Dahmer victim’s sister Rita Isbell calls out ‘money hungry’ Netflix series

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser and fridge? Here's why his belongings were sold (7)

Evan Peters stars as Jeffrey Dahmer in Netflix’s new Monster series

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's apartment?

Much like his belongings, the Oxford Apartments, where Dahmer lived, was destroyed shortly after his arrest.

Today, the site of the apartment building is now just a huge, empty green space surrounded by a tall metal fence.

In the Netflix series, we see Glenda Cleveland (Niecy Nash) request that a memorial of some kind be placed on the lot in memory of the victims. In real life, nothing was ever placed there, and there's no reference to Dahmer or anything honouring his victims on the lot.

Read more about Netflix's DAHMER here:

WATCH: Drag Race UK’s Just May claps back at Danny Beard's shady confessional remarks

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser and fridge? Here's why his belongings were sold (8)

Drag Race UK’s Just May Claps Back At Danny Beard's Shady Remarks | Drag Race Yearbook

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's dresser and fridge? Here's why his belongings were sold (2024)

FAQs

What happened to all of Jeffrey Dahmer's belongings? ›

Instead of keeping them, the head of the civic group, real estate magnate Joseph Zilber, destroyed the items, and the families of the victims compensated with the $407,225 raised during the auction. At the time, Zilber said his aim was that "these tools of death be permanently destroyed".

Who bought Jeffrey Dahmer's refrigerator? ›

Joseph Zilber, head of the civic group, pledged $407,225 to buy Dahmer's fridge, the dressers, the knives, and everything else that was up for sale. (The items also included the acid drum, clothing, bedsheets, saw blades, sledgehammers and things like records, tapes, bicycles and figurines.)

What was in Dahmer's refrigerator? ›

'I open up the door, I see a human head in a small cardboard box in the bottom of the refrigerator. ' Horrifically they also discovered two skeletons, a pair of severed hands, two severed penises, a mummified scalp, as well as three more torsos dissolving in a 57-gallon drum of acid.

Whose head was in Jeffrey's Fridge? ›

One of his last victims was Oliver Lacy, 24, whose body Dahmer had sex with before dismembering the corpse. He kept Lacy's head and heart in his refrigerator, and his skeleton in a freezer.

Can I buy Jeffrey Dahmer's stuff? ›

Cult Collectibles offers a smorgasbord of alleged Dahmer memorabilia. The Milwaukee Monster's ash vase is the "rarest true crime item I will ever have on this site," said Taylor James, boss of Cult Collectibles. Cult Collectibles is selling a photo of Dahmer in the fifth grade for a whopping $3,500.

What was found in Jeffrey's apartment? ›

The authorities found 11 bodies in Dahmer's apartment after his arrest in 1991, along with blood stains, seven skulls, two hearts, two skeletons, a pair of severed hands, multiple dismembered torsos, and other human organs. They also found Polaroid photos, weapons, and acid.

Who was the worst serial killer? ›

7 of History's Most Notorious Serial Killers
  • Jack the Ripper. We call him “Jack the Ripper,” but we don't really know who the person behind one of the older and most notorious murder sprees was. ...
  • Jeffrey Dahmer. ...
  • Harold Shipman. ...
  • John Wayne Gacy. ...
  • H.H. Holmes. ...
  • Pedro Lopez. ...
  • Ted Bundy.

What did they find in Jeffrey Dahmer's kitchen? ›

A more detailed search of the apartment, conducted by the Milwaukee police's Criminal Investigation Bureau, revealed a total of four severed heads in Dahmer's kitchen. A total of seven skulls—some painted, some bleached—were found in Dahmer's bedroom and inside a closet.

Whose head was in Dahmer's box? ›

The 86-year-old said that he once stumbled across the wooden box that contained the head of Anthony Sears, who was murdered by Dahmer in 1989. At the time, Jeffrey was staying with Lionel's mother, who resented him keeping X-rated materials in the Wisconsin house.

What were Jeffrey Dahmer's last words? ›

Jeffrey Dahmer

Convicted of murdering 17 young men, Dahmer was killed by a fellow inmate in prison on November 28, 1994. His final words, spoken to his killer, were eerie: "I don't care if I live or die. Go ahead and kill me." Dahmer's resignation hinted at the tormented soul behind the monstrous acts.

Who is Jeffrey's first victim? ›

Dahmer picked up his first victim, Steven Hicks as a hitchhiker, three weeks after his high school graduation. Dahmer promised Hicks a ride to a concert, but first, took him back to his family home where he had been living alone. He was 18 at the time.

How many heads were in Dahmers' fridge? ›

In July 1991, AP News detailed in an article that has since been taken down that a frantic handcuffed man led police to Jeffrey's fly-infested apartment, which was crawling with fragments of human bodies and boasted a refrigerator full of human heads — three of them to be exact.

Where are Jeffrey Dahmer's ashes? ›

Lionel went to court to honor Jeffrey's final wishes

Per Jeffrey's wishes, most of his remains were cremated that September, and the ashes were split between his parents.

What happened to the Oxford Apartments? ›

213 Oxford Apartments in Milwaukee between May 1990 and his arrest on July 22, 1991. Today, the site where The Oxford Apartments once stood is completely empty. The apartments were demolished in November 1992, just 15 months after human remains were discovered.

Did they really auction off Jeffrey Dahmer's stuff? ›

In order to provide them with some sort of financial comfort, a judge ordered all of Dahmer's possessions to be auctioned off to the highest bidder. The proceeds of that auction would be split between the families.

What happened to Jeffrey Dahmer's glasses? ›

James acquired the glasses and other Dahmer memorabilia a few years ago, after a former housekeeper of Dahmer's father, Lionel Dahmer, contacted him, according to reports. The collector agreed to manage and sell the collection through Cult Collectibles for a portion of the profit.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jerrold Considine

Last Updated:

Views: 6101

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jerrold Considine

Birthday: 1993-11-03

Address: Suite 447 3463 Marybelle Circles, New Marlin, AL 20765

Phone: +5816749283868

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Air sports, Sand art, Electronics, LARPing, Baseball, Book restoration, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Jerrold Considine, I am a combative, cheerful, encouraging, happy, enthusiastic, funny, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.